Pro tip: Wait at least 30 seconds for the primer to dry for the lashiest lashes. Also the packaging is kuh-yoot. Free Shipping on Orders of $99 Our latest articles, guides, and more, delivered daily. Below, you’ll find the best mascaras for sensitive eyes, including two picks from the experts. Free Shipping on Orders of $99 Presented in a pretty rose gold tube, this mascara has a thick brush that is soft on lashes. The wand isn’t precise for individual lashes, but we didn’t mind this because it creates instant eye-opening volume. Our eyelashes felt supple too, and not at all spiky or tough to touch. This meant they were comfortable throughout the day, and we didn’t find ourselves rubbing or itching our eyes. This is an affordable castor oil-infused mascara that is both kind to eyes and big on lash-thickening.

mascara for very sensitive eyes